Illinois Data Bank

Dataset tracking DOIs marked as retracted in Crossref as of April 2023 but no longer marked in Crossref as retracted as of July 2024

This project evaluates the quality of retraction indexing metadata in Crossref. We investigated 208 DOIs that were indexed as retracted in Crossref in our April 2023 union list (Schneider et al., 2023), but were no longer indexed as retracted in the July 2024 union list (Salami et al., 2024), despite still being covered in the Crossref database. Therefore, we manually checked the current retraction status of these 208 DOIs on their publishers’ websites to ascertain their actual status.

Social Sciences
Crossref; Data Quality; Retraction indexing; Retracted papers; Retraction notices; Retraction status; RISRS
CC0
Perrin Moorhead Grayson and Bruns Grayson Fellowship at the Harvard Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study (2024-2025)
Alfred P. Sloan Foundation-Grant:G-2022-19409
U.S. National Science Foundation (NSF)-Grant:2046454
Malik Oyewale Salami
83 times
Version DOI Comment Publication Date
1 10.13012/B2IDB-5333456_V1 2025-09-08

5.31 KB File
73.8 KB File

Contact the Research Data Service for help interpreting this log.

RelatedMaterial destroy: {"material_type"=>"Presentation", "availability"=>nil, "link"=>"https://hdl.handle.net/2142/129059", "uri"=>nil, "uri_type"=>nil, "citation"=>"Si, L., Salami, M. O., & Schneider, J. (2025). \r\nData Quality Assessment of Retracted Papers: Patterns and Retraction Status Shifts in Titles", "dataset_id"=>2983, "selected_type"=>"Presentation", "datacite_list"=>nil, "note"=>nil, "feature"=>nil} 2025-09-19T16:34:30Z
RelatedMaterial destroy: {"material_type"=>"Dataset", "availability"=>nil, "link"=>"https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-2907908_V1", "uri"=>nil, "uri_type"=>nil, "citation"=>"Si, Luyang; Salami, Malik Oyewale; Schneider, Jodi (2025) Dataset on tracking the data quality landscape of retracted papers: Flag usage in titles and changes in DOI retraction status. University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. https://doi.org/10.13012/B2IDB-2907908_V1", "dataset_id"=>2983, "selected_type"=>"Dataset", "datacite_list"=>nil, "note"=>nil, "feature"=>nil} 2025-09-19T16:34:30Z
Research Data Service Illinois Data Bank
Access and Use Policies Web Privacy Notice Contact Us